What on earth has happened to NuGet?

After several months away from NuGet, I had to use it again recently in VS2015. I’m completely and utterly gobsmacked at how poor the current experience is. It’s confusing, inconsistent and hard to use. Worse than that, it enables workflows that should never, ever be permitted within a package management system.

First experiences with the NuGet dialog

When I first saw the previews of VS2015, I thought that the non-modal, integrated dialog into VS would be a good thing. Unfortunately, it suffers from not making it clear enough what the workflow is. You’re bombarded with dropdowns that sometimes have only one option in them, search boxes in non-intuitive positions, installation options that you don’t want to see etc.

Let’s start by adding a package to a solution. This is a common task so should be as easy as possible. Here I’m adding my old friend Unity Automapper to two projects in a solution (note that I’ve deliberately downgraded to an earlier version of the Automapper) :-

nuget1Why so many options? Why a dropdown for Action that only has one item in it? What does the “Show All” checkbox do – looks like nothing to me at this point. Are there projects hidden from the list? Why?

Working with packages

Next let’s try to do something to the package e.g. uninstall or update. You go to Manage Packages for Solution. You don’t see the packages that you’ve already – instead, you see all packages available, ordered by (I assume) most popular download. My installed package is nowhere to be seen. How do I find installed packages only? Oh. You have to click “Filter” and then select “Installed”. That’s not what I thought of doing when I selected the menu option. I thought it would just show it to me – it took me a good few seconds to realise what had happened!

Also notice that the default dependency behaviour is “lowest” – I don’t like this. Highest should be the default, or maybe Highest Minor. Nine out of ten times you’ll just have to upgrade them all immediately afterwards anyway. Which brings me nicely onto the subject of upgrading NuGet packages…

Upgrading dependencies

So now I’ve found my package, I want to upgrade it. So I choose to manage packages for solution, and change the action from Uninstall to Update. It picks the latest version available (good).

nuget2But then notice in the screenshot above it allows me to uncheck some of the projects within the solution. What?? Why would you want to explicitly upgrade only some of the projects within the solution! I can maybe think of some corner cases, but generally this is a definitely no-no – a recipe for absolute disaster. At best you’ll muddle on with some binding redirects, at worst you’ll get a runtime error at some indeterminate time in the future when you try to call a method that doesn’t exist. What happens if you have a breaking change between the two? Which version will get deployed? Can you be sure? Don’t do this. Ever. I can’t even understand why NuGet offers you as the user to do this.

Even worse, if you choose to update a NuGet dependency at the project level (by e.g. right clicking the references node in VS), VS will upgrade it on that project alone. The other projects that have that dependency will be left untouched. You’ll end up with different versions of a dependency in a solution without you even realising it.

But let’s see what happens if we decide to live dangerously and go ahead anyway. Firstly, NuGet will happily upgrade half our solution and leave the other half in an old state – no warnings of impending doom, no nothing. Your code might work, it might not. Maybe it’s work fine for some weeks, and then you’ll realise that the upgrade has a breaking change, but you only notice this when project A tries to call a method that no longer exists.

The next time you next enter the NuGet panel to work with your dependencies – e.g. to uninstall the dependency, you’ll see the following: –

Nuget3Why is only one of my two projects showing in the list of projects that I want to uninstall? Because it’s filtering it on that specific version of the dependency (1.1.0). I have to choose the version that I want to uninstall. I don’t want that – I just want to uninstall the entire dependency. But no, we have to do it version by version. If we now change the Action to “Update”, the Version dropdown suddenly has a different meaning. It no longer acts as a filter – it’s now stating what version we’ll upgrade to. Instead, you now filter based on the projects checked in the list below. So the meaning of each user control has changed based on the action you’re performing. This is not good UI design.

UI Thoughts

In fact, the UI as a whole is really, really confusing. There are also other issues – it’s slow. You can’t upgrade all projects through the UI yet, so either you have to fall back to the Package Manager console, or upgrade each package one by one. Of course, after you do any single update, the UI reverts back to showing “All” packages which involves loading the top results from NuGet. This takes a few seconds. Then you need to change the dropdown to show “Installed” packages, and start all over again.


I’m really worried having seen the new NuGet now. It’s been in VS2015 for a while – and developers are putting up with this? It’s slow. It’s not a well designed UI – even I can tell that. You don’t feel like you know what is actually going to get deployed. The workflows don’t really work. It’s not good.

And it’s not just the UI that concerns with me NuGet. It’s also the fundamental structure underneath it that is unchanged and needs to be fixed. NuGet should be managing dependencies across an entire solution as the default and ensuring that dependencies across projects are stable. Instead, we have individual package.config files on each project, each with their own versions of each dependency. This is not what you want! As illustrated above, it’s very possible – and in fact quite likely on a larger project – that you’ll quickly end up with dependencies across projects with different versions. I’ve seen it lots of times. You run the risk of getting runtime bugs or crashes, and worse still, ones that might only be identified when you go down a specific code path in your app, probably the day after it goes live.

I was hoping that NuGet in VS2015 would start to address these issues, but unfortunately it seems like a large step backwards at the moment.


2 thoughts on “What on earth has happened to NuGet?

    1. Great news – I’ll be sure to check this out when it’s out! Do you have any plans to fix the more fundamental issues with nuget that I mentioned such as stable versioning of dependencies across projects?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s