Infragistics vs Janus

We’ve started using Infragistics as our toolset of choice for Windows Forms programming. I can’t stand it! I’ve been using the Janus control set for the past few years and have grown to really like it. It has a few small issues but generally fits in very well alongside / in place of standard Windows Forms controls. The API is very similar to the standard Windows one. The controls look good. The designers are well written.

I wish I could say the same for the IG toolkit. They seem to have been written by people coming from a Javascript background, as loads of properties for controls are backwards compared to the standard Windows ones e.g. instead of a Visible boolean property, you get a Hidden boolean property. The controls look impressive but you generally have to play around with the "AppStylist" tool to get what you want – and it’s very confusing to use! The designers are the last bit – I can’t stand most of them. They are slow, poorly designed, and difficult to navigate your way around.

Some of the controls are plain strange, too. What’s the IG equivalent of a standard Combo Box? Not the UltraDropDown, or even the UltraCombo – but the UltraComboEditor! Talking of the DropDown – this is one of the most unusual controls I’ve ever seen. It’s a good idea – a control which can be used to resolve lookups in Grids etc. However, the visual implementation is absurd. It’s a non-visual component i.e. it resolves data, and serves no purpose on the screen. However, instead of sitting in the toolpane alongside e.g. ToolTip providers, Error providers, and BindingSources etc., you actually get a physically list control on your Form at design time. When you run the application, it magically disappears from the screen though – so it behaves like a non-visual component at run time but at design-time it’s a visual control.

I’ve put the first of no doubt what will be a multitude of questions to the support team – let’s hope they are helpful!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s